So, last night, there was a debate among the candidates for governor of New York state.
There quite a few people on the stage.
Jimmy McMillan from the Rent is too Damn High Party thinks rents are too damn high in New York City and cannot spell tenant. I agree with him that the rents in New York City are indeed too high. He proposes to set up a strict city wide rent ceiling to deal with it. I disagree. After all, decades of rent control and real estate market manipulation by the government is what brought about the current situation in New York City and the surrounding area. Abolish rent control, get rid of the artificial supply restrictions caused by set aside subsidized housing, eliminate government subsidies for those who "purchase" $700,000 apartments, and you might get somewhere.
Charles Barron, a former Black Panther, thinks diversity of opinion is tied to the ethnic and racial heritage of a person, on which we disagree. He also thinks taxes in New York State are not progressive enough! Instead of lamenting the fact only a few New Yorkers are rich, he wants to penalize success even more, failing to see the relationship between the tax burden and how the wealth flee the state the first chance they get. He literally asked How about taking it out on the rich?
Howard Hawkins wants to cut the tax cuts for the rich.
As with everyone else who keeps repeating that refrain, he fails to realize that even if the government confiscates everything "the rich" make, there isn't enough money to feed the ever-expanding appetite of the New York State government. We seem to agree that there is no need to for a whole bunch of targeted taxes and subsidies. Make the tax code, both at the Federal and the State level, simpler. Income is income. It ought not to matter whether you make that income painting houses, trading stocks or driving trains. How about a flat tax, Mr. Hawkins?
Kristin Davis from the Anti-Prohibition Party, wants pot, prostitution, and gambling legalized. Fine. However, she fails to realize, at the rate New York State is going, we are all going to end up prostituting ourselves to pay for MTA's union workers wages and benefits, gambling our earnings away for a chance to "make it," and getting high to forget about it all.
Warren Redlich from the Libertarian Party started out by pointing out the salary of the head of the New York Public Library: A whopping $689,000. That, actually, seems to be progress, my friends, because, according to a New York Times article from 2006, the library's president and chief executive was $800,000 just a few years ago. We'll agree that cutting the size and reach of the government in New York State would reduce the burden on the people of New York State. When people work for themselves, rather than to feed the tens of thousands of bureaucrats whose inflated salaries, benefits and pensions form the bulk of the state's expenditures, incredible things happen.
Mr. Cuomo was polished and at home on stage. He represents business as usual. He represents the party that gave us Elliot Spitzer and prevented Governor Patterson from running for Governor. He does not question whether government programs should exist. He talks about cutting waste and fraud in those programs. He talks about operating "the system" better. I know a lot of people will fall for that, but that's just playing around the margins. "The system" is the problem.
Mr. Paladino was completely unpolished. He could not time his responses well. He frequently ran out of time without being able to complete his sentences. He seemed to have been heavily coached to try to avoid making gaffes. He was trying to be someone he isn't. But, his main point is sound: Central government is not the answer. He is the only real alternative to Mr. Cuomo's "business as usual".
Maybe he won't be able to get anything done because he won't be able navigate Albany. But, we in New York State are at the point where it would be better for the state government not to be able to do anything than do something.
It was refreshing to see most of the candidates agree that the burden of the state government is too high and that various "targeted" programs that have been going on for decades are deadweight on the people of New York State.
It was depressing that all candidates other than Mr. Paladino basically represent the interests of the New York City area.
I wish there had been a straight debate between Mr. Paladino and Mr. Cuomo, the only two credible candidates.